An ice maker almost never fails at a convenient moment. It slows down first, then drops a tray of half-formed cubes, then quits, and the evening turns into a hunt for a part number stamped somewhere on the back wall of the freezer.
What this category actually contains is the hardware that keeps a refrigerator’s ice maker running: replacement assemblies, complete kits, an inline filter for the water feed, and one countertop machine for households that would rather skip the fridge altogether. I compared what each listing really covers, whether it names the part numbers it supersedes, which model families it fits, and how much of the repair job it takes on, then scored them with the BHK Score system used across this site.
My overall pick for best refrigerators with ice maker is the FrigeSwift 4317943 Icemaker Kit for Whirlpool. Its listing pairs a long compatible model list with an equally long list of replacement part numbers, so you can match the sticker inside the freezer to the page before anything ships. My top picks are just below.
Our Top Picks
| Product | BHK Score | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Best Overall FRIGESWIFT Icemaker Kit for Whirlpool with | 9.9 | Check Price on Amazon | |
| Samsung DA97-15217D Ice Maker Assembly | 9.9 | Check Price on Amazon | |
| Best for Moderate Use ORFLROA Countertop Ice Maker with 26-Pound Daily | 9.9 | Check Price on Amazon | |
| Best for Long-Term Use AQUA CREST INL Water Filter with 5,000 Gallon | 9.8 | Check Price on Amazon | |
| REEPLAR Ice Maker Replacement for Frigidaire | 9.8 | Check Price on Amazon | |
| Nurfosttek Ice Maker Kit for Whirlpool with Wide | 9.7 | Check Price on Amazon | |
| Frigidaire 241798231 Ice Maker Assembly Kit | 9.6 | Check Price on Amazon | |
| Best for GE Refrigerators Parts Master GE Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement | 9.4 | Check Price on Amazon | |
| Best for Bosch Thermador Refrigerators Salugre OEM 12028493 Refrigerator Ice Maker | 9.4 | Check Price on Amazon | |
Full Reviews
Replacement icemaker kit sized 11.4 by 4.6 by 4.8 inches for specific Whirlpool models.
Key Facts
- Dimensions
- 11.4 x 4.6 x 4.8 inches
- Compatible Models
- Whirlpool AH530-720/01, A8RXNGMWB00 series
- Replacement Part Numbers
- RIM943, 4210317, 797991, 625601, W10122496, 833701, W10281545, W10190952
Pros
- +Compatibility with a broad range of Whirlpool refrigerator models
- +Compact size designed to fit specific fridge icemaker slots
- +Multiple replacement part numbers covered for easier sourcing
Cons
- −Limited to Whirlpool models only, not universal for other brands
- −Physical size may not suit refrigerators with larger icemaker bays
- −No additional accessories included beyond the kit itself
Detailed Review
This FRIGESWIFT icemaker kit measures 11.4 by 4.6 by 4.8 inches which fits a range of Whirlpool refrigerators including models AH530-720/01 and A8RXNGMWB00 series. It replaces specific part numbers such as RIM943 and W10122496 ensuring compatibility with various Whirlpool units.
I'd consider this kit primarily for households needing a precise replacement part for these Whirlpool models rather than a universal fit. The physical size is a key factor to check before purchase since it may not suit fridges with different icemaker compartment sizes.
Worth knowing before you buy is that this kit includes only the icemaker assembly without extra components. Its fitment focus means it's best suited to Whirlpool users who want an exact match replacement rather than a generic option.
Samsung DA97-15217D is a genuine OEM refrigerator ice maker assembly with a compact 1-inch cube size.
Key Facts
- Dimensions
- 1 x 1 x 1 inches
- Color
- White
- Included
- Ice Maker Assembly
Pros
- +Exact replacement for various Samsung ice maker part numbers
- +Compact dimensions suitable for tight refrigerator compartments
- +Genuine OEM construction for assured fit and function
Cons
- −Limited to Samsung models using listed part numbers
- −No detailed material or durability information provided
Detailed Review
The Samsung DA97-15217D is a genuine OEM ice maker assembly designed specifically to replace several Samsung part numbers including DA97-15217A and DA97-15217B. This ensures compatibility for Samsung refrigerators that require these specific replacements. The unit is compact, measuring just 1 x 1 x 1 inch, making it suitable for tight spaces inside the ice maker compartment.
I see this working best for those needing a direct replacement part rather than a universal option. Worth knowing before you buy is the limited information on materials or construction, which means durability expectations must rely on Samsung's OEM standards. This part fits major appliance ice maker assemblies and comes in white, which is standard for blending into most refrigerator interiors.
For my money, this suits homeowners focused on maintaining their existing Samsung refrigerator ice maker function without altering the original design.
ORFLROA countertop ice maker produces 9 bullet ice cubes every 6 minutes with a compact, portable design.
Key Facts
- Dimensions
- 11.3 x 8.8 x 10.4 Inches
- Daily Ice Production
- 26 Pounds
- Ice Cube Production Time
- 9 Cubes in 6 Minutes
- Noise Level
- Below 45 Decibels
Pros
- +Produces 9 ice cubes within 6 minutes
- +Lightweight design supports portability for camping or office use
- +Detachable ice basket simplifies maintenance
- +Sound-dampening keeps noise under 45 decibels
Cons
- −Limited color options with only jet black available
- −Manual cleaning required to maintain hygiene
- −Maximum daily output may not suit large households
Detailed Review
This ORFLROA ice maker stands out with its ability to produce 9 bullet-shaped ice cubes in just 6 minutes and a maximum daily output of 26 pounds, which fits well for family gatherings or small events. Its compact size measuring 11.3 by 8.8 by 10.4 inches makes it practical for kitchens with limited counter space or for portable use during camping trips. The inclusion of a detachable ice basket and scoop facilitates straightforward cleaning and upkeep. I see this unit working best in settings where quick ice production is needed without excessive noise, as the machine keeps sound below 45 decibels. Worth knowing before purchase is the manual cleaning process which requires regular attention to maintain optimal hygiene. This ice maker suits users looking for a reliable, space-saving option for moderate daily ice needs.
This AQUA CREST inline water filter reduces chlorine and odors with a 5,000-gallon service life for refrigerators and ice makers.
Key Facts
- Capacity
- 5,000 Gallons
- Dimensions
- 3.38 x 3.38 x 10.78 inches
- Material
- Polyester membrane and coconut shell carbon
- Included
- 1/4" tubing and multiple fittings
Pros
- +Long 5-year or 5,000-gallon service life reduces replacement frequency
- +Multiple 1/4-inch fittings support plastic or copper water lines
- +BPA-free and lead-free materials for safer water contact
Cons
- −Does not reduce total dissolved solids (TDS) in water
- −Relatively large 10.78-inch length may limit tight installation spaces
- −Requires careful 20mm tube insertion to prevent leaks
Detailed Review
This AQUA CREST inline water filter offers a 5,000-gallon service life which can last up to five years depending on water conditions. It features both compression and push-to-connect fittings for 1/4-inch plastic or copper tubing, allowing installation without cutting the line if tube insertion is precise. The filter uses a polyester membrane and 0.5-micron coconut shell activated carbon to reduce chlorine, taste, odor, rust, and suspended solids, improving water flavor from refrigerators or ice makers.
I rate this a reasonable pick for users needing long-lasting filtration with straightforward installation options. Worth knowing before you buy is that it does not reduce total dissolved solids (TDS), so it won’t remove all mineral content. The filter’s 10.78-inch length is somewhat bulky for cramped under-sink or appliance spaces.
Overall, I see this working best for households wanting extended filter life and compatibility with multiple fridge brands or RV water systems. The included fittings and tubing provide a near-complete installation kit which simplifies setup.
This REEPLAR ice maker replacement fits specific Frigidaire, Electrolux, and Kenmore models and includes a built-in wiring harness for straightforward installation.
Key Facts
- Dimensions
- 6 x 5 x 12 inches
- Included
- Built-in wiring harness
Pros
- +Includes built-in wiring harness for simple replacement
- +Fits multiple OEM part numbers for broad compatibility
- +Compact size suitable for standard refrigerator ice maker space
Cons
- −Not a universal fit; requires model confirmation before purchase
- −Limited to certain Frigidaire, Electrolux, and Kenmore refrigerators
Detailed Review
This REEPLAR ice maker replacement measures 6 by 5 by 12 inches and includes a built-in wiring harness, which simplifies the installation process by allowing a straightforward plug-and-play swap. It replaces numerous OEM parts such as 241798224 and 241642511, making it compatible with a specific range of Frigidaire, Electrolux, and Kenmore refrigerator models.
I'd consider this a reasonable pick if your ice maker has stopped producing ice, emits unusual noise, or fails to shut off properly. Worth knowing before you buy is the product is not universal and requires verifying compatibility with your refrigerator model to avoid fit issues.
This ice maker suits homeowners comfortable with basic appliance repairs who need a direct replacement part without extra features or adjustments.
Replacement ice maker kit compatible with Whirlpool, KitchenAid, and Kenmore models, designed for efficient and stable daily ice production.
Key Facts
- Dimensions
- 4.8 x 11.4 x 4.6 inches
Pros
- +Wide compatibility with multiple refrigerator brands and models
- +Solid construction reduces frequent wear and tear
- +OEM-compatible size and mounting for direct replacement
Cons
- −No detailed power consumption or efficiency ratings provided
- −Limited to specific part number replacements only
Detailed Review
The Nurfosttek 4317943 ice maker kit is designed to fit Whirlpool, KitchenAid, and Kenmore refrigerators, matching part numbers W10122496, W10281545, and W10190952. This ensures a precise fit without requiring modifications during installation. The kit uses well-selected raw materials that contribute to a stable running state and reduce frequent wear. I see this kit working best for users needing a reliable replacement for aging or malfunctioning ice maker units.
Installation is straightforward, allowing ordinary users to complete it with basic tools. Worth knowing before purchase is the absence of detailed power consumption data, which might be relevant for energy-conscious buyers. Overall, this kit suits households aiming to restore ice production steadily without complex maintenance.
Frigidaire 241798231 is an ice maker assembly kit designed to exact specifications with a compact size of 11.75 by 4.62 by 4.12 inches.
Key Facts
- Dimensions
- 11.75 x 4.62 x 4.12 Inches
Pros
- +Precise engineering for compatible Frigidaire refrigerator models
- +Compact size fits well inside standard refrigerator compartments
- +Installation guidance specifies necessary tools and skill level
Cons
- −Requires experienced DIY skills for proper installation
- −Limited to refrigerators compatible with this specific assembly kit
- −No included tools necessitates separate purchase or availability
Detailed Review
The Frigidaire 241798231 ice maker assembly kit measures 11.75 by 4.62 by 4.12 inches, making it a compact replacement part for compatible refrigerators. This size is important for ensuring it fits within the appliance without requiring modifications. It is engineered by Frigidaire to meet exact specifications, which helps maintain the performance integrity of the refrigerator's ice maker system.
Installation is intended for users with some DIY experience and requires specific tools including a 1/4 inch nut driver, gloves, and safety glasses. I see this working best for those comfortable with appliance repairs who want to avoid professional service costs. Worth knowing before you buy is that this part is made only for certain models, so checking compatibility with your refrigerator manual is critical to avoid installation issues.
I'd consider this a reasonable pick for those needing a genuine replacement part to ensure proper function. The white finish is standard and blends with most fridge interiors, but this kit is not a universal fit and requires some repair skill to install correctly.
Replacement ice maker for GE refrigerators producing up to 2 lbs of ice daily with on/off switch and fill adjustment.
Key Facts
- Dimensions
- 9.75 x 5.5 x 5.25 Inches
- Weight
- 2.41 Pounds
- Capacity
- 2 lbs ice per 24 hours
Pros
- +Wide compatibility with 80+ GE part numbers
- +Includes water fill adjustment for precise control
- +Compact size suitable for many GE refrigerators
- +On/off switch allows easy ice production control
Cons
- −Limited ice production capacity for large households
- −No detailed material or certification information provided
- −Weight of 2.41 pounds may require careful installation
Detailed Review
This Parts Master replacement ice maker fits many popular GE refrigerators with its compact 9.75 by 5.5 by 5.25-inch footprint. It is designed to produce up to 2 pounds of ice every 24 hours, which suits typical household needs but might be insufficient for heavy ice users. The inclusion of an on/off switch and a water fill adjustment screw provides control over ice production and water volume, which helps tailor performance to specific fridge models.
I see this working best for those needing a direct swap for a faulty or leaking ice maker in compatible GE models without requiring additional modifications. Worth knowing before you buy is the lack of detailed material specifications or certifications, which limits insight into long-term durability or safety features. Installation care is advised given the unit’s moderate weight of just over 2 pounds.
For my money, this replacement suits homeowners looking for a straightforward, functional fix to restore ice production in their GE refrigerators.
This OEM ice maker fits Bosch and Thermador refrigerators and measures 5 x 3.8 x 12 inches for a compact replacement solution.
Key Facts
- Dimensions
- 5 x 3.8 x 12 Inches
- Compatible Brands
- Bosch, Thermador
- Replacement Part Numbers
- 4962577, AP6894086, PS12729871, EAP12729871
Pros
- +Compatibility with Bosch and Thermador refrigerators
- +Replacement for several part numbers including 4962577 and AP6894086
- +Compact dimensions suitable for typical fridge ice maker spaces
Cons
- −No explicit wattage or power specification provided
- −Limited to compatibility with specific refrigerator brands
- −No mention of included installation accessories or tools
Detailed Review
The Salugre OEM 12028493 ice maker is designed specifically for Bosch and Thermador refrigerators, replacing multiple part numbers such as 4962577 and AP6894086. Its compact dimensions of 5 by 3.8 by 12 inches make it suitable for standard ice maker compartments without requiring extra space. I see this part working best for households needing a direct replacement rather than a universal fit.
The product is made from high-quality materials aimed at resolving issues like malformed ice or water leakage, which are common with aging ice makers. Customer support includes options for replacement or refund, which adds a layer of confidence when ordering.
Worth knowing before you buy is that it only fits specific refrigerator models, so verifying compatibility is essential. I rate this a reasonable pick for those with compatible Bosch or Thermador units seeking a straightforward replacement.
FAQs
How do I find the right ice maker replacement for my refrigerator?
Match the model number on the plate inside the refrigerator against the listing’s compatibility list, then confirm the replacement numbers it names. Assemblies are model-specific, so a similar-looking unit from another brand rarely mounts or plugs in cleanly. Photograph the plate before ordering, because reading it upside down with a flashlight gets old fast.
What is the difference between a genuine OEM part and an aftermarket ice maker kit?
A genuine OEM part is built to the original factory specification, while an aftermarket kit is built to fit the same mounting position and part numbers at a lower cost. Neither is automatically the better buy, since the deciding factor is how confidently the listing names your model and the numbers it supersedes. Check the appliance manual before installing either one.
Do countertop ice makers need a water line?
Countertop machines carry their own reservoir and need no plumbing, so you fill them by hand and empty the basket as ice melts. That suits renters and small kitchens without a fridge line, though it means refilling and cleaning on a routine schedule. Follow the maker’s cleaning instructions rather than improvising with household cleaners.
Does an inline water filter change the taste of ice?
An inline filter sits on the water feed and reduces chlorine, taste and odor before the water reaches the ice maker, so cubes come out cleaner tasting. It will not fix a mechanical fault, and it does not lower total dissolved solids. Replace the cartridge on the schedule the manufacturer specifies for your water conditions.
Final Thoughts
Fit comes before everything else here. An assembly that names your exact model and the part numbers it supersedes will get ice flowing again, while one that merely looks similar will not. Water quality and daily ice volume are the second and third questions, and both get easier to answer once the part is confirmed.
For most Whirlpool-family refrigerators, the FrigeSwift 4317943 Icemaker Kit for Whirlpool is the best overall choice. Its compatibility list runs long enough to catch older model families that other listings skip, and the part-number cross reference lets you verify the match from the freezer wall instead of guessing at a product photo. It suits the household nursing a decent fridge through one more repair rather than shopping for a new one.
The budget pick is a different kind of purchase. The AQUA CREST INL 5 Years Inline Water Filter for Ice repairs nothing, but it improves what the ice tastes like for the smallest outlay in this group, and the push-to-connect fittings keep the install to a single twist. If your cubes freeze properly but taste flat or chlorinated, start there before spending on an assembly.
The right pick removes the part-number guessing that makes this category frustrating in the first place, and that is all most kitchens actually need.