8 Best Bagel Making Kits for Chewy Homemade Bagels (2026)
I compared 8 bagel making kits from Baketivity, Crumble Crate, Sliner in November 2026, weighing boards, pre-measured mixes, and kid-friendly bundles. The picks below suit everyone from first-time bakers to families who want a weekend project.
Bagel making kits look simple on the shelf. A board, a bag of flour, a recipe card. But the difference between a kit that produces a chewy, golden bagel and one that ends up as a dense puck usually comes down to two things: whether the tools match the method, and whether the instructions actually explain the boil step.
I went through the listings for the best bagel making kits, comparing what each box actually contains, how the boards are built, and whether the recipes are written for beginners or assume you already know how to shape a ring. The BHK Score ratings on this site come from that same research process: materials, stated contents, and care instructions, cross-referenced with verified ratings where they are disclosed.
My overall pick for best bagel making kits is the Sliner 2 Pcs Bagel Baking Boards Cedar Pine Wood. It is the simplest entry point into real bagel baking, because the cedar boards and burlap do the one job that separates bagels from round bread: holding the dough through the boil and into the oven without it collapsing. My top picks are just below.
Our Top Picks
| Product | BHK Score | ||
|---|---|---|---|
|
Best Overall Sliner Cedar Pine Bagel Baking Boards with Burlap | 9.9 | Check Price on Amazon |
|
Best for Family Projects Baketivity Sourdough Bagels Kit for Family Baking | 9.9 | Check Price on Amazon |
|
Best for Family Activity Baketivity Bagels Kids Baking Kit | 9.8 | Check Price on Amazon |
|
Best for Kids Baking Baketivity Rainbow Bagel & Pretzel Baking Kit | 9.8 | Check Price on Amazon |
|
Best for Home Bakers Sliner Cedar Pine Bagel Baking Boards Set of 3 | 9.7 | Check Price on Amazon |
|
Baketivity Rainbow Bagel Kids Baking Kit | 9.7 | Check Price on Amazon |
|
Best for Beginner Bakers Crumble Crate New York Style Bagel Kit | 9.6 | Check Price on Amazon |
|
Best for Kid Baking Baketivity Pretzel & Bagel Baking Kit Bundle | 9.5 | Check Price on Amazon |
Full Reviews
Sliner's two-piece bagel baking board set is made from cedar pine with burlap liners, sized 15.7 by 3.5 inches for home baking batches.
Key Facts
- Size
- 15.7 x 3.5 x 0.8 inches per board
- Material
- Cedar pine with burlap liner
- Included
- 2 boards and instruction manual
- Weight
- 1.43 pounds
Pros
- +Two boards allow baking multiple bagels at once
- +Cedar pine wood offers natural moisture resistance
- +Burlap liner helps seeds adhere to bagels
- +Includes instruction manual for new bagel bakers
Cons
- −No stated oven-safe temperature limit for the wood
- −Hand-wash likely required to protect cedar and burlap
- −Limited to bagel-sized batches, not larger loaves
Detailed Review
The Sliner bagel baking boards are a two-piece set made from cedar pine with burlap liners, each board measuring 15.7 by 3.5 by 0.8 inches. That size is built for standard home oven racks, and the two-board count means you can bake a small batch of bagels without rotating trays. The burlap side is designed to hold seeds in place when you flip the bagel, which is the step that usually sends sesame or poppy seeds scattering across the oven floor.
I see this working best for home bakers who already make bagels or sourdough and want a more authentic crust without buying a full bakery setup. The cedar is described as moisture-resistant, which matters because bagels need a damp surface to develop that chewy interior. Worth knowing before you buy, the listing gives no oven-safe temperature rating for the wood, so you will need to follow the included manual for safe use. The burlap also means these boards are not a wipe-clean tool, so plan on hand washing and thorough drying after each bake.
For my money, this is a reasonable pick for someone who bakes bagels in small batches and wants a dedicated board rather than improvising with a sheet pan. It is not a substitute for a full baking stone, and the 15.7-inch length limits you to standard bagel sizes rather than large loaves.
A complete sourdough bagel kit with tools, recipe booklet, and online class led by Sarah Leitner for family baking.
Key Facts
- Dimensions
- 1 x 3 x 2 inches
- Included
- Slotted spoon, silicone baking mat, bench knife, stopwatch timer, multi-lid topping shaker, recipe and activity booklet, online class access
- Series
- Eighth kit in the 12-month Sourdough Schoolhouse program
- Class Instructor
- Sarah Leitner of Spice & Zest
Pros
- +Complete tool set removes guesswork for first-time bagel bakers
- +Online class adds step-by-step guidance on shaping and boiling
- +STEM booklet connects baking steps to real science concepts
- +Multi-lid shaker simplifies even topping application
Cons
- −No sourdough starter included in the kit contents
- −Online class requires separate screen and internet access
- −Compact dimensions may limit workspace for large batches
Detailed Review
The Baketivity Sourdough Bagels Kit bundles a slotted spoon, silicone baking mat, bench knife, stopwatch timer, and multi-lid topping shaker into one box, which is more than most bagel kits offer. The included recipe and activity booklet pairs each step with a STEM concept like hydration or starch gelatinization, so the boiling and shaping process doubles as a science lesson for kids.
I see this working best for families who want a structured weekend project rather than a solo baking session. The online class with Sarah Leitner of Spice & Zest walks through dough preparation, shaping, boiling, and topping, which fills the gap for anyone who has never made bagels from scratch. Worth knowing before you buy, the kit does not include a sourdough starter, so you will need an active starter on hand before the first batch.
The compact box dimensions also mean the tools store easily but the workspace is limited to what you supply. For my money, this suits households with kids aged around eight and up who can handle the bench knife and boiling water with supervision, and it follows the manufacturer's instructions for safe handling.
Baketivity Bagels Kids Baking Kit
The Baketivity Bagels Kids Baking Kit includes pre-measured, vacuum-packed dry ingredients and educational activities for a family baking session.
Key Facts
- Size
- 14.25 x 9.5 x 2.63 inches
- Weight
- 1.98 pounds
- Included
- Pre-measured dry ingredients and educational activities
- Certification
- Certified Kosher
Pros
- +Pre-measured ingredients reduce measuring and cleanup
- +Vacuum-packed dry ingredients stay fresh until use
- +Certified kosher ingredients made in a USA facility
- +Compact 14.25-inch box stores easily in a pantry
Cons
- −No wet ingredients included, so milk or eggs may be needed
- −Limited to bagels, with no alternate recipe options
- −Requires oven use and adult supervision for children
Detailed Review
The Baketivity Bagels Kids Baking Kit centers on a pre-measured, vacuum-packed dry ingredient set that removes the measuring and guesswork from a family baking session. The kit measures 14.25 by 9.5 by 2.63 inches and weighs about 1.98 pounds, so it stores on a pantry shelf without taking over the kitchen. I see this working best for a rainy-day activity or a sleepover where the goal is a shared project rather than a from-scratch cooking lesson.
The included educational activities give kids something to do while the bagels bake, which helps fill the waiting time. The ingredients are certified kosher and manufactured in a USA facility, a detail that matters if you keep a kosher kitchen or simply prefer a stated sourcing standard. Worth knowing before you buy, the kit supplies only dry ingredients, so you will need to check the recipe for any wet components before you start.
For my money, this suits families with young children who want a structured, low-mess baking project. The main trade-off is flexibility, since the kit is built around one bagel recipe and does not offer alternate options. Adult supervision is required because the bagels go into the oven, so follow the manufacturer's instructions for safe handling.
A two-kit bundle with pre-measured kosher dry ingredients, illustrated recipes, QR video tutorials, and STEM lessons for ages 6-12.
Key Facts
- Size
- Bundle of 2 kits
- Included
- Rainbow bagel kit and soft pretzel kit
- Ingredients
- Kosher-certified, USA-manufactured dry ingredients
- Age Range
- Ages 6-12+
Pros
- +Pre-measured pouches reduce measuring mistakes for young bakers
- +Two recipes in one bundle add variety to family baking sessions
- +QR video tutorials support kids who learn better by watching
- +Color-coded pouches match illustrated recipes for easier following
Cons
- −Requires fresh add-ins from home before baking can start
- −Kosher dry ingredients only, no wet components included
- −Ages 6-12+ guidance means younger kids need adult supervision
Detailed Review
This bundle pairs two Baketivity kits, rainbow bagels and soft pretzels, in one box with pre-measured kosher dry ingredients split into individually packaged pouches. The color-coded pouches match the illustrated recipes, so a young baker can follow along without hunting for the right bag mid-step.
I see this working best for families who want a structured weekend project rather than free-form kitchen play. The QR codes link to video tutorials with Baketivity's head chef for each recipe, which helps kids who learn by watching rather than reading. The STEM angle is built into the measuring, mixing, and shaping steps rather than tacked on as a separate worksheet.
Worth knowing before you buy, the kits include dry ingredients only, so you'll need to add fresh items from home before either recipe can start. I'd rate this a reasonable pick for households with kids in the 6-12 range who already enjoy hands-on kitchen time.
Set of three cedar pine bagel boards with burlap, each 15.7 inches long, for baking multiple bagels at once.
Key Facts
- Size
- 15.7 x 3.5 x 0.8 inches per board
- Material
- Cedar pine wood and burlap
- Included
- 3 boards and instruction manual
Pros
- +Three boards for baking multiple bagels simultaneously
- +Cedar pine wood offers natural moisture resistance
- +Burlap side helps seeds stick to bagels, not plate
- +Instruction manual included for guidance
Cons
- −No stated oven-safe temperature limit in product data
- −Hand-wash only likely required for wood and burlap
- −Specific care and maintenance instructions not detailed
Detailed Review
Each Sliner bagel board measures 15.7 by 3.5 by 0.8 inches, and the set includes three boards plus a detailed instruction manual. That size and count let me bake several bagels at once, which suits small-batch home baking and sourdough experiments. The cedar pine build is intended to provide natural moisture resistance and stability, while the burlap side is designed to hold seeds like sesame or poppy in place so they stick to the bagel rather than the plate.
I see this working best for home bakers who want to try New York-style bagels without buying a full bakery setup. The process is straightforward: dampen the linen side, place the bagel on the board, and bake. Flipping is made easier by the board design, which helps achieve an authentic crust. The main trade-off is that the product data does not state a specific oven-safe temperature rating, so I would follow the manufacturer's instructions for safe use.
For my money, this suits bakers making small batches who want a dedicated tool for bagels and similar baked goods. Worth knowing before you buy: the wood and burlap construction likely requires hand washing and careful drying to maintain shape and performance. I rate this a reasonable pick for anyone ready to move beyond a baking sheet.
Baketivity Rainbow Bagel Kids Baking Kit
A kosher, USA-made kids baking kit with pre-measured ingredients for making rainbow bagels, aimed at ages 6 to 12 and supported by a QR video guide.
Key Facts
- Size
- Baketivity Kit
- Weight
- 1.74 lb
- Rating
- Kosher, USA-made
- Included
- Pre-measured ingredients and step-by-step instructions
Pros
- +Pre-measured ingredients simplify setup for young bakers
- +QR video guide adds interactive support during baking
- +Kosher, USA-made kit with straightforward included tools
- +STEM-focused instructions build measurement and direction-following skills
Cons
- −No stated capacity or yield for the finished bagels
- −Limited to a single rainbow bagel recipe, no flavor variety
- −Requires a QR scan and screen access for the video guide
Detailed Review
The Baketivity Rainbow Bagel kit centers on pre-measured ingredients and kid-friendly instructions, turning bagel-making into a guided activity for ages 6 to 12. The QR code video guide from the head baker adds a screen-based layer of support, which helps when a child wants to see a step rather than read it.
I see this working best as a weekend project or gift for a child who likes cooking, since the STEM framing ties measurement and instruction-following to a real result. The kit is kosher and USA-made, and the listing notes no fancy gadgets are required, just simple tools.
Worth knowing before you buy, the data gives no yield or capacity for the finished bagels, and the kit is tied to one rainbow recipe with no flavor variety.
Crumble Crate New York Style Bagel Kit
A bagel-making kit with pre-measured bread flour, barley malt syrup, yeast, and three toppings. Includes tools and a recipe card to make eight bagels.
Key Facts
- Yield
- 8 full-size bagels
- Prep Time
- 45 minutes
- Bake Time
- 20-25 minutes
- Included
- Pre-measured ingredients, toppings, parchment, towel, chopsticks
Pros
- +All dry ingredients pre-measured, skipping the shopping step
- +Recipe card and QR videos guide the boil-and-bake technique
- +Shaping chopsticks and parchment included for immediate start
- +Makes eight full-size bagels for a family brunch
Cons
- −Requires a 45-minute prep plus 20-25 minute bake, not a quick project
- −No cream cheese, lox, or other serving ingredients included
- −Recipe card and videos are the only instructions, no printed booklet
Detailed Review
The Crumble Crate kit arrives with pre-measured bread flour, barley malt syrup, active dry yeast, and three toppings (everything seasoning, poppy seeds, sesame seeds), so the shopping list is already handled. What sets it apart is the included shaping tools: parchment paper, a kitchen towel, and chopsticks for forming the holes. The recipe card and QR-code videos walk through the boil-then-bake step that gives a New York bagel its shiny crust and dense chew.
I rate this a reasonable pick for a weekend project with teens or a family baking session, since the difficulty is listed as 2 of 4 and no bread experience is needed. The main trade-off is time: 45 minutes prep plus 20-25 minutes in the oven, so it is not a last-minute breakfast. Makes eight full-size bagels, enough for a small household or a brunch gathering.
Worth knowing before you buy: the box contains no cream cheese, lox, or serving ingredients, so plan a separate grocery run for toppings. For my money, this suits anyone who misses a proper deli bagel and wants the technique spelled out rather than guessed.
Baketivity Pretzel & Bagel Baking Kit Bundle
A two-kit bundle with pre-measured kosher dry ingredients, illustrated recipe cards, and QR video guides for making soft pretzels and bagels.
Key Facts
- Included
- 2 Baking Kits (Pretzel & Bagel)
- Age Range
- Ages 6+
- Ingredients
- Pre-Measured Kosher Dry Ingredients
- Instructions
- Illustrated Cards & QR Video Guides
Pros
- +Pre-measured dry ingredients cut down on measuring and mess
- +Two separate kits offer pretzel and bagel variety in one purchase
- +Illustrated cards plus QR video guides support independent kid baking
Cons
- −Wet ingredients still require a separate shopping trip
- −Bundle price is higher than a single baking kit
- −No stated allergen or dietary certification beyond kosher labeling
Detailed Review
This bundle pairs two Baketivity kits, one for soft pretzels and one for bagels, with pre-measured kosher dry ingredients in vacuum-sealed packs. The shopping list for fresh and wet items is the practical catch, since you still need to buy those before baking starts. I see the illustrated recipe cards and QR video guides as the real differentiator for ages 6 and up, giving kids visual steps from the head baker rather than a wall of text.
For a family night or a rainy afternoon, the two-kit format means pretzels and bagels are not a one-and-done activity. USA-made dry ingredients and the mess-free measuring setup suit households that want less cleanup and more hands-on time. I'd consider this a reasonable pick for parents who want a structured project rather than free-form baking.
Worth knowing before you buy, the bundle costs more than a single kit and the wet-ingredient shopping trip adds a step. For my money, it suits gift-giving and supervised kid baking best.
FAQs
What is the difference between bagel boards and a baking stone?
Bagel boards are wooden planks wrapped in burlap that carry the boiled dough into the oven and get flipped partway through, while a stone is a flat surface you bake directly on. The board protects the dough during the flip and helps the crust set evenly. If you already own a stone, a board kit still adds the flip step that gives bagels their signature texture.
Do you need a stand mixer to use a bagel making kit?
A stand mixer makes kneading easier, but none of these kits require one. The dough for a small batch of bagels is stiff enough to knead by hand in about ten minutes. For families baking with kids, hand kneading is often the better choice because it keeps everyone involved and lets you feel when the dough is ready.
How many bagels does a typical kit make?
Most kits are portioned for a small batch, often around eight full-size bagels per box. That is enough for a weekend breakfast for a family of four, or a few days of leftovers. If you plan to bake for a crowd, check the stated yield on the listing before buying, since bundles that include two recipes will produce more.
Are bagel making kits good gifts for someone who does not bake?
They work well for beginners when the kit includes a written recipe and a video walkthrough, because the boil step is the part most new bakers get wrong. A board-only set suits someone who already bakes bread, while a pre-measured ingredient kit removes the shopping trip. Either way, the recipient should read the manufacturer’s instructions before starting.
Final Thoughts
The thing that matters most in this category is whether the kit matches how you actually bake. A board set teaches the technique and lasts through repeated batches, while a pre-measured ingredient box is better for a one-time family project or a gift. Decide which of those you want before you start comparing boxes.
For most home bakers, the best overall choice is the Sliner 2 Pcs Bagel Baking Boards Cedar Pine Wood. The cedar boards and burlap give you the flip step that produces a crisp exterior and chewy interior, and the set works with any dough recipe you already like. It suits someone who wants to learn the method rather than follow a single mix.
If you want the lowest-cost way into bagel baking, the Sliner 3 Pcs Bagel Baking Boards Cedar Pine Wood adds a third board for baking more bagels at once, which helps when you are feeding a household or prepping a batch for the freezer. Either Sliner set removes the guesswork around the flip, which is the step most first-time bagel bakers struggle with.